New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday dismissed two applications filed by the Tamil Nadu government seeking directions to Karnataka to release 11 thousand million cubic (TMC) feet of Cauvery river water to the state.
A bench comprising Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh rejected the pleas, which sought immediate clearance of the water shortfall recorded as of October 7. Tamil Nadu had also requested that Karnataka release the water at a rate of 1.3 TMC per day over 10 days at Billigundulu, a key water-measuring point along the Karnataka-Tamil Nadu border.
The court also indicated that a third application filed by Tamil Nadu to place additional documents on record would be dismissed.
Why Did Tamil Nadu Approach The Supreme Court?
Tamil Nadu had approached the apex court on August 3, alleging that Karnataka had failed to release its required share of Cauvery water during the distress period.
The state argued that it was seeking its legitimate pro-rata share of available water, along with the accumulated shortfall. It maintained that the burden of reduced rainfall and water availability should not fall entirely on the lower-riparian state, particularly when farmers were facing difficulties due to inadequate irrigation supplies.
Tamil Nadu also questioned the decisions of the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC) and Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA), arguing that the prescribed releases were insufficient to clear the backlog.
Karnataka Cites Drought And Drinking Water Needs
Karnataka opposed Tamil Nadu’s demand, telling the court that the state was facing a difficult rainfall-deficit year, with several areas declared drought-affected.
Its counsel argued that releasing the additional 11 TMC feet would be difficult and that the state needed to conserve available water to protect drinking water supplies in residential areas.
Karnataka also referred to the northeast monsoon in Tamil Nadu, arguing that rainfall during November could replenish the neighbouring state’s reservoirs, while the same rainfall pattern would not provide similar relief to Karnataka.
What Had The Cauvery Water Authority Directed?
The dispute also involved directions issued by the CWMA following meetings of the regulatory bodies.
At its September 24 meeting, the CWRC assessed the water deficit at Billigundulu and directed Karnataka to ensure a flow of 4,000 cusecs for the next 15 days. The authority subsequently reduced the prescribed flow to 3,000 cusecs from October 9 for another 15-day period.
Tamil Nadu contended that Karnataka had not fully complied with the directions and that the releases were inadequate to address the accumulated shortfall.
The state also argued that a clear distress-sharing formula had not been finalised despite the CWMA’s formation, leaving uncertainty over how Cauvery water should be distributed during years of inadequate rainfall.