New Delhi: The Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court that social media content creators and reel-makers cannot automatically claim the protections available to journalists while covering protests, arguing that the distinction between professional reporters and online creators is important for managing demonstrations.
In affidavits filed before the Supreme Court, Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar defended the police action during protests against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar at Jantar Mantar last month.
The affidavits were submitted in response to petitions filed by the Network of Women in Media, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and other media organisations. The petitions alleged police excesses against journalists and media personnel covering the protests.
Delhi Police Questions Whether Reel-Makers Qualify As Journalists
In its submissions, Delhi Police said some participants in what it described as “illegal protests” were content creators recording YouTube reels while carrying cameras and microphones.
According to the police, this made it difficult for personnel deployed at the protest site to distinguish professional journalists from individuals creating social media content.
The police maintained that its guidelines for journalists covering protests were intended to identify professional reporters and distinguish them from people using cameras and microphones for other purposes, including the commercial exploitation of content.
The affidavits stated that journalists constitute a distinct category from social media content creators and that the latter cannot automatically claim the same protections while covering protests.
“In the present era of evolving digital media, several individuals, whether creative or otherwise, make reels, upload them and commercially exploit the content created by them. While there can be no objection to such activities, the question as to whether such reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined,” the police submitted.
Police Says Journalists’ Work Was Not Intentionally Obstructed
Delhi Police also said it respected the role of the press and had not intended to prevent content creators from carrying out their activities.
The affidavits maintained that the distinction was raised to explain the practical difficulties faced by police personnel while managing protests, rather than to obstruct genuine journalistic work.
“The predominant intent behind the activity may be the decisive factor” in determining whether an individual is functioning as a journalist or a content creator, the police submitted.
It further clarified that it had not sought to obstruct, impede or interfere with the bona fide discharge of journalistic duties during the protests or otherwise.
Delhi Police Refers To Supreme Court’s Earlier Direction
The police also referred to an earlier direction issued by the Supreme Court concerning the protection of journalists while performing their professional duties.
According to the affidavits, the direction was intended to protect journalists carrying out their work and was not meant to exempt social media influencers, reel-makers or unruly elements from general laws or lawful directions issued by law enforcement agencies at a prohibited assembly.
The submissions come amid petitions by media organisations alleging that journalists faced police excesses while reporting from the Jantar Mantar protests. The police’s position is now part of the arguments placed before the Supreme Court.